Nominee
Project
Role Type
Criteria
Xavier has made an significant impact on the project.
Currently he is one of the most active contributors in this project, in fact he is currently at the 6th position of the individual contribution activity.
https://github.com/eclipse-score/communication/commits/main/?author=lim…
He is mainly focused on keeping the overview of the "big picture". As a sideline activity always working on making the code compliant to newer C++ Versions.
It is my pleasure to nominate Xavier as a committer on Eclipse Safe Open Vehicle Core.
Nominated by
Date
-
Status
This election failed due to a veto from the PMC.
| Voter | Vote | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Jochen Hönle | +1 | +1 implied by nomination |
| Jan Schlosser | +1 | Also contributions in: https://github.com/eclipse-score/baselibs/commits/main/?author=limdor |
| Ulrich Huber | +1 | |
| Lukasz Tekieli | +1 | |
| Anton Krivoborodov | +1 | |
| Alexander Schemmel | +1 | |
| Markus Bechter | +1 | |
| Alexander Lanin | 0 | Lots of commits over the last 2 months - which is great! Although I cannot judge quality. Anyway 2 months is not quite enough for a +1 from my side. |
| Andrey Babanin | +1 | |
| Dan Calavrezo | 0 | Update: based on the protocol, I will just abstain. But my comment still remains valid. as compared to Brendan, who has been active since May, Xavier has only been active the past couple of months There are no issues assigned or created by him https://github.com/eclipse-score/score/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20assignee%3Alimdor https://github.com/eclipse-score/communication/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20author%3Alimdor it's a no from me at the moment ( just based the vote on the Eclipse Committer Guide) |
PMC Approval
- Andy Riexinger (-1) Dear Xavier, the Automotive PMC rejected the committer election, as we see not too many contributions in the S-CORE repo. "See blog post of Wayne Beaton, Director of Open Source Projects, Eclipse Foundation: To be considered for committer status a candidate must demonstrate merit. Generally, this takes the form of making high-quality contributions to a project in the form of patches or new code, but can manifest in other ways. At this point, we would like to point to the typical workflow according to the Eclipse Project Handbook. (https://www.eclipse.org/projects/handbook/#contributing) Means, we expect Pull Requests authored by you, which merges your contributions into the main path. Keep on going with your work in the S-CORE project and feel free to restart the election with additional evidence, like links to your PR´s.