Nominee
Project
Role Type
Criteria
It is a pleasure to nominate Dirk Blank (dblankevia) as a committer to the Eclipse Eclipse Tractus-X project.
Dirk Blank in the lead developer of the Trace-X FOSS Impl. team.
His contribution to the product is the implementation of notifications in trace-x and the integration of other services like IRS to the Trace-X solution.
Github:user dblankevia
List of his PR:
https://github.com/catenax-ng/product-traceability-foss-backend/pulls?q…
Nominated by
Date
-
Status
This election failed with a -1 vote from a project member.
| Voter | Vote | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Martin Kanal | +1 | +1 implied by nomination |
| Jaro Hartmann | +1 | |
| johannes zahn | +1 | |
| Maximilian Ong | +1 | |
| Sebastian Bezold | -1 | While all the contributions look good, none of them is actually based on Eclipse Foundation Infrastructure. Before passing the committer election, there should be prove, that working in the EF context is understood. So possible improvements for the election would be links to eclipse-tractusx contributions or reviews on eclipse-tractusx contributions. If we can see that in the nomination, i can update my vote |
| Carsten Lenz | -1 | No direct contributions to Eclispe-Tractusx yet. For a committer election I would have expected contributions to Eclipse-Tractusx instead of contributions to our previous Catenax-NG GH organization. I guess this is not the intended way for a committer election and it might be unfair to Devs who collect contributions to Eclipse-Tractusx with the aim of a committer election. |
| Siegfried Kiermayer | -1 | Please share what he did in eclipse context and not in catenax-ng context; Reelection shouldn't be a problem then i think. |