Details Nominee: Lucas CapellinoProject: Eclipse Tractus-XRole Type: CommitterCriteria: Hello Tractus-X Community/Committer, I would like to nominate Lucas Capellino (GitHub handle https://github.com/ds-lcapellino) to become a committer in the Eclipse Tractus-X project. Lucas has contributed documentation to multiple Tractus-X repositories. He maintains the Trace-X FOSS product in eclipse-tractusx.github.io. He is an experienced developer who has shown expertise in backend development and good knowledge of software architecture. His notable contributions to various projects showcase his skills, emphasizing transparency and a strong commitment to maintaining high software quality standards. Some of his contributions are listed below. He contributed to various Tractus-X repositories: Trace-X FOSS - https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/traceability-foss/pull/632 - https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/traceability-foss/pull/751 IRS - https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/item-relationship-service/pull/467 - https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/item-relationship-service/pull/451 Portal - https://github.com/catenax-ng/tx-portal-frontend/pull/426 Testdata Provider - https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/testdata-provider/pull/3 Lucas has shown that he understood the concepts of the Tractus-X Release Guidelines and is continuously coming up with solutions on how to implement/optimize them: https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/traceability-foss/pull/826 - https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/traceability-foss/pull/833 Here is an example of an issue he opened, in case he needed help from SIGs: - https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/sig-infra/issues/455 It is recommendable to include Other Community contributions: - Reviews and harmonization (i.e. https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/item-relationship-service https://github.com/eclipse-tractusx/traceability-foss/) - Advocacy and outreach - Q&A in the matrix channel https://matrix.to/#/#tractusx-irs:matrix.eclipse.org https://matrix.to/#/#tractusx-trace-x:matrix.eclipse.org It is my pleasure to nominate ds-lcapellino as a committer on Eclipse Tractus-X. Nominated by: Martin KanalDate: Thursday, May 2, 2024 to Thursday, May 9, 2024 Status Status: This election failed with a -1 vote from a project member.Votes: VoterVoteComments Martin Kanal+1+1 implied by nomination johannes zahn+1conducted very good work. Fabian GrĂ¼n+1 Jaro Hartmann+1 Sebastian Bezold-1EDIT: Changing from 0 to -1. I asked for better updated input on the mailing list, since the provided PRs in the nomination are not sufficient. I think it was a fair amount of time to do that, but there has not been any public reaction. Would have also expected a reply to the other feedback mail Mathias Brunkow Moser+1 Stephan Bauer+1 Maximilian Wesener+1Lucas did some great work in the tractus-x participations. +1 Paul Latzelsperger-1I don't think those contributions are up to the standards of an OSS project. More details via mailing list, this page screws up my formatting. Malte Hellmeier0 Carsten Lenz0Like others already mentioned, I don't like the PR management (no reviews, PR is opened by A containing contributions of B and B is merging the PR, PRs fork:main -> upstream:main). At least one of the PRs should have required an IP Check (> 1000 lines of code changed) but there is no hint that this has been done. This doesn't reflect well on the committer merging the PR, too. In the same PR DEPENCIES file hasn't been updated (in addition the checkmark istn't checked in PR). Florian Rusch-1I agree with Paul. Especially in the sometimes chaotic world of OSS, we should focus on following best practices and rules. Unfortunately, I see some shortcomings in Lucas' PRs in this regard. Evelyn Gurschler0