Reviews run for a minimum of one week. The outcome of the review is decided on this date. This is the last day to make comments or ask questions about this review.
The goal of this release is to create a(n additional) Servlet Container Lite profile, and a REST profile. The existing SOAP profile is to be marked as stable. We'd like to update the Java 1.4 API to Java 5 (introduce generics) and clarify some spec text.
The items are further explained below:
1. Clarify interactions with other specs ✅
1.1 Clarify that the application Jakarta EE component namespaces (java:app,
java:comp, etc) should be available from within a ServerAuthModule.
Practical use case: obtaining application scoped data sources, EJB beans
and other resources.
Example: new InitialContext().lookup("java:app/myds")
1.2 Clarify that the CDI default scopes for web components (@RequestScoped,
@SessionScoped, etc) should be available from within a SAM.
Practical use case: obtaining application scoped identity stores
Example: CDI.current().select(SomeBean.class); // SomeBean is @RequestScoped
2. Clarify the register session feature
The spec text regarding how the "register session" feature should work is unclear.
The spec lead under the JCP clarified this feature at various occasions and made the
remark that the spec should have said something about the groups. These clarifications
should be added to the spec text.
3. Expand the TCK ✅
The TCK is not optimally testing the basics yet, and a few simple (but crucial) tests
should be added.
4. Update the Java SE level ✅
Jakarta Authentication's API is still limited to Java SE 1.4. which feels curiously out of place
in Jakarta EE 9, let alone Jakarta EE 10.
In practice this mostly boils down to adding generic parameters for the
various maps Jakarta Authentication passes around. Where it makes sense default methods for
interfaces could be considered.
5. Detect invocation via authenticate() ✅
A ServerAuthModule can be called at the start of a request or following a call to
A simple key in the message info map would suffice to distinguish between
those two cases. Various implementations already have such a key in place,
or have e.g. a boolean for this in the runtime method just before the ServerAuthModule
6. Introduce a factory method to register only a ServerAuthModule ✅
The end user of Jakarta Authentication, as well as integrators such as Jakarta Security implementations almost always just care about registering a ServerAuthModule. Yet the AuthConfigFactory only accepts an AuthConfigProvider, which is essentially a "wrapper-wrapper-wrapper-wrapper" of a ServerAuthModule to the end user. A new method should be added to the AuthConfigFactory to only register a ServerAuthModule.
The JDK version required will be aligned with Jakarta EE 10.