Eclipse Corrosion™: the Eclipse IDE for Rust 1.0.0 Release Review

Type
Release
Graduation
State
Successful
End Date of the Review Period

Reviews run for a minimum of one week. The outcome of the review is decided on this date. This is the last day to make comments or ask questions about this review.

Release

1.0.0

API Certification

The project leadership certifies that the APIs in this release are "Eclipse Quality".

Architectural Issues

Corrosion uses Rust Language Server with LSP4E and Rust TextMate grammar with TM4E to provide a rich editor for Rust files; and uses CDT to provide debugger for Rust programs in the Eclipse IDE.

It integrates well with the Eclipse IDE, does not overlap with any other project (on the contrary, it adds only a small bit of configuration over other projects that provide most of the solutions).

Corrosion is the main piece of the "Eclipse IDE for Rust developers" EPP package.

It is not extensible (no extension points, all packages marked as internal) as there is no identified need for extensibility identified so far.

For these reasons, Corrosion is a project that doesn't require much maintenance ot remain usable and profitable.

Security Issues

None.

Non-Code Aspects

Corrosion has some Contribution guide, a README, some release notes and troubleshooting documentation

Conforms To UI/UX Guidelines
Not verified
Usability Details

Corrosion mostly uses UI elements that are provided by other projects, so it is consistent in usability with what those projects provide.

It adds some wizards and launch configuration, which are designed with care on usablity, minimizing amount of necessary clicks, amount of things to read for users

Communities

The user community is relatively big (estimated to ~6000 people (latest EPP package + Marketplace installs over a year without releases).

About 20 users (non contributors) have participated to issue discussions on the last year.

Corrosion is adopted as part of the "Eclipse IDE for Rust developers" package. No other integration of Corrosion is known at the moment.

The developer community is active, especially in updating to latest versions of dependencies, altough not much maintenance is required on Corrosion itself. The committers team is diverse and consists of people working for 3 different organizations.